Ombudsman report exposes ‘brutality’ of Australia’s immigration detention network, Greens say | Australian immigration and asylum


Serious concerns about long-term immigration detention and the use of force in detention centres have been raised by the man responsible for keeping Australian government agencies in check.

The commonwealth ombudsman, Michael Manthorpe, in his half-yearly report released on Friday, acknowledged general improvements in the welfare and transport of immigration detainees as well as the release of some people into the community.

But he is troubled by how long some detainees remain locked up, the use of force and shortfalls in privacy as well as mobility access within high-security compounds.

“I remain concerned that people continue to be held for lengthy periods with, in some instances, no probability of being released in the foreseeable future,” he wrote.

“Delays in resolving the immigration status of detainees place considerable strain both on detainees and their families.”

Manthorpe also said he was increasingly concerned about the use of force in immigration detention.

“There appears to be an increasing tendency across the immigration detention network for force to be used to resolve conflict or non-compliant behaviour as the first rather than last choice,” he wrote.

Manthorpe urged the home affairs department to remind staff about the consequences of using inappropriate force and improve their review systems.

He recommended the department give security contractor Serco a dressing down over its inadequate response to one complaint about the use of force and apologise to the person who made it.

“We will continue to monitor, investigate and provide feedback on issues arising from the use of force in immigration detention,” Manthorpe wrote.

The ombudsman was unhappy with the management of complaints and security risk assessments, which his office had raised previously.

He made 12 recommendations – four relating to the use of force – and eight others concerning better monitoring facilities and improving signage about legal rights.

The department agreed with most of the recommendations.

“This is yet another scathing report that exposes the brutality of Australia’s immigration detention network,” the Greens senator Nick McKim said.

“People are being detained for years, there is excessive use of force and coercion, and facilities are inadequate for people being held there.”

Manthorpe is closely monitoring the government’s response to the coronavirus, including infection controls in immigration detention centres, but says the pandemic is making inspections more challenging.

There are now 1,550 people in immigration detention on the mainland.

More than 70% of detainees have committed crimes and will be deported as a result. About 250 of the most serious criminals are being sent to Christmas Island to free up some space.

Christmas Island has previously housed asylum seekers and, more recently, people returning from the Chinese city of Wuhan in the early stages of the coronavirus pandemic.

The centre is also holding a Tamil family fighting deportation to Sri Lanka after being taken from the Queensland town of Biloela.